Affordable Restaurant in Cayman
I also received a request for a restaurant that is a locals favorite that was not Caribbean influenced. To that end, I recommend an Italian restaurant called Casanova. It is a quiet romantic and reasonably priced spot right along the harbor. Be sure to request a table by a window so you can enjoy the sunset while partaking in a nice bottle of red and an order of the Piccatina di Vitello al Limon or the penne in a tomato grappa sauce.
I could not find a web site for Casanova but here is the information from the phone book:
Casanova Restaurant
South Church Street, Fort Building
Georgetown
Tel. 949-7633